Alliance Wars - How pointless is this?

Giving resources to alliance members has been denied many times

Just hope your leader doesn't abandon your alliance, or that haypi makes it so leaders can be replaced

I see it more as donating back to the alliance. i see a loop hole on this one

res and cash i can safely say fine leave in the alliance but coins i would say is something i would be more than happy to argue as there is a finacial implication. if not redistributed at least have it returned by proportion to those who have contributed.

I just wanted to leave a small oppinion..

I feel like Haypi and games alike always need to change and grow to keep players interested.
However, i feel AW was a bit too much of a step and takes away to much from the Prestige, achievement and title aspect of the game; Vice-Leaders are always busy with managing the army and mine

After a few days of playing with alliance wars, both as a vice and as a regular member, I’ve realized that this is completely useless to the game itself. So much time, effort, and money is thrown at alliance wars, however it has no bearing on your individual character.

Honor: This seems rather pointless as Haypi never really explained what this is for. I’ve noticed some of use higher contributors sporadically get a glitchy silver medal next to our name in chat. While I have yet to reach the 15,000 honor mark, as of now, this seems to do nothing.

Mines: It was pretty fun building up the army the first few days and wage constant war. Unfortunately, right now my alliance controls a level 5 mine and has not been seriously attacked in a couple days. It seems as though most alliances have given up as there is no true benefit in spending the coins & resources on this.

Contribution: This is obviously Haypi’s money maker. Contribution points seem to be geared more towards coin-givers as I have donated millions in both resource and money, however one person dropped 1500 coins and he was immediately #1 in contribution. While it is nice to have mass coins for your alliance, he is pretty much untouchable at the top. I’m beginning to believe Haypi is incapable of adding new functions into this game that are not money driven. (i.e. city-dropping, enhancements, alliance wars)

Overall: I can’t imagine when everyone on the forums was clamoring for alliance wars, anyone had “fight over mines” in mind. Most of us wanted to coordinate attacks and defend the other players within the alliance. Either way, I still feel like alliance wars is more of a mini-game within Haypi. Perhaps if the prestige gained from a mine was reflected into each alliance members personal prestige, then capturing and holding a mine would be worth it. In the end, I think Haypi missed the mark on this one.

TWO THUMBS UP FOR YOU!! all uve said here is very very true. haypi is a money maker game.

ive been playing haypi for a week now. and for a beginner, im kinda addicted to it.

but playing it for a while made me realize that haypi is a profit game.

at 1st ure given 30 enhancement stones and 30 coins.

my alliance advised to me that i should sell the enhncement stones to npc and use the money for upgrading my buildings. and i did that.

and also the coins can be use to enhance the production of your resources.

ive also realized that upgrading my buildings are very important. cuz on that way my resources' output per hour will improve and by then, i have a better production. and also in that way i can help on our alliance by donating large amount of resources IF only i had upgrded my buildings successfully.

for now im saving coins and enhncement stones. i didnt use them all for upgrading my buildings. but what if i use them all? what will be my reason to play haypi? how can i donate to my alliance to help them if my production is low and slow cuz the only fun part for me now why im playing haypi is to help my alliance. cuz i know one purpose of this game is to be the best alliance that you can be.

but also haypi should consider that players should also enjoy playing it not because of the alliance thing. im just saying.. when it comes to the production of the resources, a player should have other ways to fasten or increase the production. cuz i noticed that all u have to do in the game is to wait.. wait.. wait.. for the resources if they increase on # already
cuz on this part, when ure out of coins and enhancemnt stones, u cant do anything but to wait this is just my suggestion.

although i enjoyed chatting especially with my alliance

trading resources on the market, upgrading my buildings, go for hunting, but all of that will fall from having more resources. in that case, as i told awhile ago -- youll end up buying coins

my alliance advised to me that i should sell the enhncement stones to npc and use the money for upgrading my buildings. and i did that.

Ouch...too bad you did that as 30 stones is worth much more in the long run.

I'm glad to see I'm not alone on this one as my alliance is ranked 2 (soon to be #1) and it's pretty boring in doing so. Any alliance that attacks our mine is simply a scout and we haven't had an actual battle in over a week. I've reach 15,000 honor points and got a lame medal next to my name.

I originally thought the pp a mine produced would be added to our personal pp, but that isn't the case. I think if HK were to allow that, then there would be an actual reason to fight for a mine.

Well, we have several strong alliances fighting each other in this pointless minigame on our server, when we are not confronted by the glitches, like entire armies disappearing (!), attacking archers controlling where the defending cats should attack, the game just closing on u all the time, the map not working properly, medals not showing properly, support not answering... Also check topic "spice up alliance wars". I'm glad the chat still works....

Shin-ra... Just want to point out one thing

30 stones doesn't go far at all. In fact, it almost always goes as far as one failed enhancement

I think alliance wars have helped embrace the working together aspect of the game. It will take some getting used to, but eventually I believe people will get more aggressive with attacking mines

I think alliance wars have helped embrace the working together aspect of the game. It will take some getting used to, but eventually I believe people will get more aggressive with attacking mines

That's the wrong way buddy

At the beginning everyone was fighting for alliances. Now nobody cares and the only attacks that are sent are 1 cav

I think alliance wars have helped embrace the working together aspect of the game. It will take some getting used to, but eventually I believe people will get more aggressive with attacking mines

That's the wrong way buddy

At the beginning everyone was fighting for alliances. Now nobody cares and the only attacks that are sent are 1 cav

lol not tru eour aliance wars are kicking off now i took 3K for our alliance yesterday